We open with a song, sung to the tune of Sinatra’s “It Was a Very Good Year”:


  • 2017
  • It was a very bad year.
  • It was a very bad year
  • For politics in the U.S.A.
  • Our president’s cray-cray!
  • His act got very old,
  • And the GOP turned cold.


  • But I’d say ‘17
  • It was a pretty good year,
  • A year when women made clear
  • That men in power would have to change!
  • That list got long and strange,
  • And many houses were cleaned –
  • The best of ’17.


  • Now as the days grow cold
  • We look for sanity.
  • We look for voices to rise and call an end
  • To hate and greed.
  • It’s all that we need
  • To make the world serene
  • In 2018.


In January, we lost Mary Tyler Moore. Yesterday, we lost Rose Marie. Make a resolution to yourselves to go to Netflix and (re)watch every episode of The Dick Van Dyke Show, one of the greatest sitcoms of all time, and you’ll know why losing these two women in one year makes me feel particularly sad.

Sorry, folks, New Year’s Eve is probably my least favorite holiday, and this year has been an inordinately gloomy one on several counts. It has been a year of growth and discovery for me, and that can be painful sometimes. Still, it was the year that I began to learn to play bridge, and that’s a positive thing no matter which way the cards land! I taught three hundred kids, directed four shows, with a lot of talent of the young person variety on display, and managed to squeeze in two classes at Stanford and lots of bridge lessons in for myself. And I got a new cat for Mimi and me, who promptly took over the house.


I sometimes berate myself for not posting more, but then I looked at the numbers: I managed eighty blog posts this year! That’s well over one a week, and why do you need to hear more from a mug like me than that?!? I also feel bad that I’m such a slow reader. My annual list looks like the Puzzle Doctor’s list for December! I only read twenty-eight books this year. But then I looked at my 2016 recap and realized that I had improved on last year . . . by two books! And if you figure that one of those books was by Elizabeth George, I actually read sixty.

I think some of the Scandinavian and other modern writers slowed me down, but my work schedule does put a crimp on my access to pure reading time. I also blame my cell phone, Netflix, and Bejeweled Blitz on Facebook.


Now, on to the topic at hand, the books I read. Here is a list:

  1. The Woman in Cabin 10 (Ruth Ware)
  2. The Closed Casket (Sophie Hannah)
  3. The Ten Teacups (Carter Dickson)
  4. She Died a Lady (Carter Dickson)
  5. Mystery in White (Jefferson Farjeon)
  6. The Case Is Closed (Patricia Wentworth)
  7. The Terrorists (Maj Sjowall and Per Wahloo)
  8. The Ice Princess (Camilla Lackburg)
  9. A Great Reckoning (Louise Penny)
  10. The Phantom Passage (Paul Halter)
  11. A Banquet of Consequences (Elizabeth George)
  12. The Emperor’s Snuff-Box (John Dickson Carr)
  13. The Case of the Counterfeit Eye (Erle Stanley Gardner)
  14. The Plague Court Murders (Carter Dickson)
  15. Rim of the Pit (Hake Talbot)
  16. The Madman’s Room (Paul Halter)
  17. Who Killed Harlowe Thrombey? (Edward Packard)
  18. The Problem of the Green Capsule (John Dickson Carr)
  19. Sometimes I Lie (Alice Feeney)
  20. The Night of the Wolf (Paul Halter)
  21. The Seven Wonders of Crime (Paul Halter)
  22. The Beacon Hill Murders (Roger Scarlett)
  23. Death in the House of Rain (Szu-Yen Lin)
  24. Glass Houses (Louise Penny)
  25. Ten Dead Comedians (Fred Van Lente)
  26. The Howling Beast (Noel Vindry)
  27. Two Thirds of a Ghost (Helen McCloy)
  28. The Problem of the Wire Cage (John Dickson Carr)

And here is a graph that I put together to help sort out that list:


Seriously, though, I was surprised to see that 28.5% of the books I read could be considered “modern” crime fiction. I guess my attempts to retreat into the past have been only partly successful.

I do Paul Halter the honor of not counting him in this category, considering that he writes in the classic style. Interestingly, Halter accounted for 14% of my reading this year. (It all sounds big when you don’t read that many books.) I will say this: as much as I complain about Halter, all in all, we got along much better this year! Yes, there was The Seven Wonders of Crime to deal with, but the rest were . . . pretty good.

It must be the company I keep, but I read a lot of impossible crimes this year. Half of this list falls into that category. Six by Carr, including the classic The Problem of the Green Capsule and one of my favorite Merrivale mysteries so far, She Died a Lady. Then there was the craziness of Rim of the Pit and The Howling Beast, both highly enjoyable. I know Death in the House of Rain should probably count as “modern” crime fiction, but it turned out to be one of my most satisfying “classic” reads of the year.


For every book I read, I think I buy three, so I see no possibility of ever burning off my TBR pile. And I have to say that, tepid as my reviewing pace may be, I never tire of revisiting Agatha Christie, Ellery Queen, Christianna Brand, Carr, and the other authors who made me the esoteric reader I am today. I also blog about films and theatre, and I even got one piece of memoir writing in there. So I guess I have been a busy boy.

Looking back on my year in blogging, one thing I think I really miss is the tempering off of the group efforts. At the start of the year, The Tuesday Night Bloggers were still going strong. Goodness knows how busy we all get, but more than anything else here, I enjoy the camaraderie I find with all of you and hope that continues and grows in the New Year.


I try through all of this to refrain from getting political. Honest to God, it has been scary sometimes this year. I think many of us have turned to classic mysteries for the same reason that people read them between the wars: to seek solace in a world gone mad by retreating to a world where order is always restored at the end. Perhaps that explains the increased re-publication of these comforting tales of serial killers and poisons that leave no traces. Who can guess what is to come, but I trust we will carve out the time to share the treasures we have uncovered in our local bookstores and movie houses, to argue jovially over this or that, and to try, in some fashion, to bring a smile to each other’s faces every day.


I leave you with the Broadway for Orlando version of “What the World Needs Now.” Truer words were never said. Love must prevail.

Happy New Year everyone.


22 thoughts on “MY END OF THE YEAR RECAP

  1. I’d call that a pretty productive year, Brad, and your regular posting is always a pleasure to peruse, even if I don’t always have the time, or perhaps more accurately, the interesting contributions to make. Anyway, the very best to you, and onward to ’18.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. What a great post, Brad! I really like your take on It Was a Very Good Year. I’m glad you got a new cat; animal companions have a really healing quality, I’ve found. And I respect you for looking back and really thinking about the reading you’ve done this past year. You make an interesting point about group efforts. Sometimes they can be fabulous experiences. Here’s wishing you all the very best for 2018!


  3. You and JJ are putting me to shame with getting your end of the year posts all written and posted already. Still not quite started writing mine yet…
    Now that you’re not doing a scandi crime course any mine and equally have probably read most of Halter’s output, what sort of reading plans/goals do you have for next year?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Kate, if you carefully look at clues many of this year’s posts, you will understand why I hate making “goals.” For example, at the ends of several, I refer to specific books sitting on my stand, as if they are about to be read and posted on soon. And yet . . . no post. That’s because I didn’t read them yet. Or the time I called one post “The Walking Dead, Part One:” That’s because my next read was supposed to be Theodore Roscoe’s zombie-murder epic . . . except I’m struggling a bit with that one and put it aside for now.

      So if you really put me on the spot, I would say that I want to at least pare down the current TBR pile, which occupies two full bookcases in my bedroom. I want to re-read the six Peter and Iris Duluth mysteries. And I had a dream of re-reading and writing a post about each of the sixty Sherlock Holmes short stories. But I want to cram in more Carr and McCloy and get to Book Two in the Harriet Rutland trilogy at last,/i> . . . and you just know that some new/old publishing miracles will come down the pike next year to distract me from there “goals.”

      Happy New Year to you and those chickens! 🙂


      • Well they sound like some good flexible goals and I do hope you make it to Rutland’s 3rd book at some point. Weirdly I’ve not really set myself any specific reading goals except participating in one reading challenge. Might try and do a bit more re-reading maybe.
        Hope you and your ever so fluffy cats have a Happy New Year too.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Loved this end-of-the-year round-up, Brad. And I agree that the kind of year it’s been has led to a definite interest in books where the bad guys get it in the end. Yes. And of course, that usually means, vintage. One of the many things I’m thankful for this year is finding your blog. Happy New Year to you.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thanks for all the posts and reviews. 🙂 Halter has appeared more than I thought he would given how you feel about him. 😛 Maybe LRI will publish more Szu-Yen Lin? I’m currently reading ‘Problem of the Wire Cage’, which TomCat mentioned to me might have been the inspiration behind Lin’s ‘Haunted Badminton Court’. Having read Lin’s novella first, ‘Wire Cage’ might turn out to be an interesting read…


    • I’m glad thing we’re better for you, Christian. I fear 2017 was about grappling with the craziness here. One only hopes some positive action is taken in the coming year to mitigate some of the damage being done.


      • I took that craziness already in advance in 2016 when the results of the election were published, so those disappointments ended up in that year. Compounded with the Brexit result of the same year, the passing away of such cultural icons as Rickman and Bowie, and finally and most importantly that my mother passed away – there’s no year that was more depressing ever in my life.

        2017 had several sad occurrences as well, but were mitigated by some unexpectedly positive results, mainly in the political arena. My view of 2017 is probably also tempered by living in a different country from you… 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Final Post of the Year | crossexaminingcrime

  7. Christian, I am sorry for the loss of your mother. And I’m grateful to have the chance to develop an international community here and across this blogosphere. Perhaps if we stick together, despite this movement to eradicate the global community, we can show ’em all how it’s done! And we can support each other in good and bad times, whether they coordinate at the same time or not! 🙂


  8. Happy New Year Brad! At least you got an end of year post out. I was felled with a post-Xmas plague, but also am just generally not up with everything, so I’m impressed by your achievements. And your graph is the finest thing I have seen in the blogosphere this year – clear, factual, but not over-simplified. I think it makes clear who your major influences are, and shows the overall importance of Dame Agatha. Well done Brad!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s